Wikibin - The Recycle Bin of Wikipedia

Salem hypothesis

The "Salem Hypothesis" (or "Salem Conjecture"), named after Bruce Salem, is the hypothesis that there is a correlation between subscribing to creationism and working in an engineering discipline.
Origins
The "Salem Hypothesis" is credited to Bruce Salem, a regular contributor to the Usenet talk.origins newsgroup. It is the "onjecture that an education in the engineering disciplines forms a predisposition to viewpoints."
Critic of creationism PZ Myers elaborated on its origin and meaning by stating:
Academic support for the hypothesis
In a paper presented to the Iowa Academy of Science, John W. Patterson stated that "engineering educators, senior engineers, and registered professional engineers are perhaps the most prominent leaders of the creationist movement." Patterson offers two possible explanations for this phenomenon:
#Lack of interest among engineering societies in policing themselves with regard to "ethical irresponsibility or scientific incompetence", allowing their membership to "publicly endorse ludicrous forms of pseudoscience without being publicly chastised by their professional societies."
#Involvement by engineers in "the rather difficult subjects of thermodynamics and fluid mechanics", allowing them to "develop confusing and yet authoritative-sounding arguments which are unintelligible to laymen."
In a working paper, Diego Gambetta and Steffen Hertog state that:
They further note that a Carnegie survey shows that "engineers turn out to be by far the most religious group of all academics", and note the relevance of the Salem hypothesis to these results.



Comments (3)
1. 12-04-2011 16:43
 
Engineering does not make significant effort to understand the underlying natures of things. It has been reduced to tabulated data that is referenced to maintain optimal design. Engineering, in this sense, relies on faith in the arbitrary data presented in those reference materials. This methodology is, in essence, defaulting to a higher authority to validate your own positions. That is entirely consistent with Creationism and Intelligent Design. 
 
Furthermore, there is a certain level of self-adulation in viewing god as the designer, or engineer, of the universe. It is an ego validation that engineers are more 'godlike' than others.
Guest
 
2. 12-04-2011 20:12
 
After decades of working with engineers, I have observed that there are some that tend to live in a world somewhat disconnected from reality. This might predispose them to be theists, who also live in a world that has rejected reality.  
 
When your days are absorbed with thoughts and actions that separate you from co-workers and your thought processes are involved with solving obscure problems, it could make you more susceptible to religion and its scams.
Guest
 
3. 20-07-2011 18:52
 
Frankly I think that's asboleulty good stuff.
Guest
 

Write Comment
Name:
E-mail
Comment:

Code:* Code
I wish to be contacted by email regarding additional comments

 
< Prev   Next >