Outer Critics Circle Award for Outstanding Direction of a Play

The Outer Critics Circle Award for Direction of a Play, formerly the award for Director of a Play, is an annual award given to the best director of a (non-musical) play on Broadway or Off-Broadway, as determined by Outer Critics Circle. The award has been given out since the 1992–1993 season, when the Best Director award split and renamed into musical and play categories. In 2024, the award was renamed to Outstanding Direction of a Play.

Jack O'Brien has won the most awards, with four, followed by Joe Mantello with three awards. Daniel J. Sullivan has received the most nominations with eight, followed by Joe Mantello and Jack O'Brien with seven and six nominations, respectively.

Award winners

Key

1990s

Year

Director

Production

Ref.

1993

Daniel J. Sullivan

The Sisters Rosensweig

1994

George C. Wolfe

Angels in America and Twilight: Los Angeles, 1992

1995

Joe Mantello

Love! Valour! Compassion!

1996

Lloyd Richards

Seven Guitars

1997

John Caird

Stanley

Anthony Page

A Doll's House

Daniel J. Sullivan

An American Daughter

Ron Lagomarsino

The Last Night of Ballyhoo

1998

Michael Mayer

A View from the Bridge and Side Man

Matthew Warchus

Art

Ethan McSweeny

Never the Sinner

Garry Hynes

The Beauty Queen of Leenane

1999

Howard Davies

The Iceman Cometh

Robert Falls

Death of a Salesman

Patrick Marber

Closer

Trevor Nunn

Not About Nightingales

2000s

Year

Director

Production

Ref.

2000

Daniel J. Sullivan

A Moon for the Misbegotten and Dinner with Friends

Peter Hall

Amadeus

Michael Blakemore

Copenhagen

David Leveaux

The Real Thing

2001

Jack O'Brien

The Invention of Love

John Tillinger

Judgment at Nuremberg

Daniel J. Sullivan

Proof

Ian McElhinney

Stones in His Pockets

2002

Mary Zimmerman

Metamorphoses

Scott Schwartz

Franz Kafka's The Castle

Daniel J. Sullivan

Morning's at Seven

Jeremy Sams

Noises Off

George C. Wolfe

Topdog/Underdog

2003

Joe Mantello

Take Me Out

Gerald Gutierrez

Dinner at Eight

Michael Wilson

Enchanted April

Michael Engler

Talking Heads

2004

Jack O'Brien

Henry IV (both parts)

Moises Kaufman

I Am My Own Wife

Daniel J. Sullivan

Intimate Apparel

Doug Hughes

Frozen

2005

Doug Hughes

Doubt

Dan Wackerman

Counsellor-at-Law

Joe Mantello

Glengarry Glen Ross

John Crowley

The Pillowman

Anthony Page

Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?

2006

Nicholas Hytner

The History Boys

Bartlett Sher

Awake and Sing!

Jerry Zaks

The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial

Wilson Milam

The Lieutenant of Inishmore

2007

Jack O'Brien

The Coast of Utopia

David Grindley

Journey's End

Michael Grandage

Frost/Nixon

Melly Still

Coram Boy

2008

Anna D. Shapiro

August: Osage County

Rufus Norris

Les Liaisons Dangereuses

Rupert Goold

Macbeth

Maria Aitken

The 39 Steps

2009

Matthew Warchus

The Norman Conquests

Moisés Kaufman

33 Variations

Bartlett Sher

Joe Turner’s Come and Gone

Garry Hynes

The Cripple of Inishmaan

Anthony Page

Waiting for Godot

2010s

Year

Director

Production

Ref.

2010

Michael Wilson

The Orphans' Home Cycle

Stanley Tucci

Lend Me a Tenor

Doug Hughes

The Royal Family

Kenny Leon

Fences

2011

Marianne Elliott and Tom Morris

War Horse

Emma Rice

Brief Encounter

Anna D. Shapiro

The Motherfucker with the Hat

Daniel J. Sullivan

Good People

2012

Nicholas Hytner

One Man, Two Guvnors

Mike Nichols

Death of a Salesman

Mark Brokaw

The Lyons

David Cromer

Tribes

2013

Jack O'Brien

The Nance

Nicholas Martin

Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike

Bartlett Sher

Golden Boy

Michael Wilson

The Trip to Bountiful

Pam MacKinnon

Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?

2014

Tim Carroll

Twelfth Night

Bill Rauch

All the Way

Lyndsey Turner

Machinal

Michael Grandage

The Cripple of Inishmaan

Lindsay Posner

The Winslow Boy

2015

Marianne Elliott

The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time

Stephen Daldry

The Audience

Jeremy Herrin

Wolf Hall

Scott Ellis

The Elephant Man

You Can't Take it With You

2016

Ivo van Hove

A View from the Bridge

Evan Cabnet

Gloria

Rupert Goold

King Charles III

Joe Mantello

The Humans

Mike Donahue

The Legend of Georgia McBride

2017

Rebecca Taichman

Indecent

Kate Whoriskey

Sweat

Jack O'Brien

The Front Page

Daniel J. Sullivan

The Little Foxes

Lila Neugebauer

The Wolves

2018

John Tiffany

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Marianne Elliott

Angels in America

Jo Bonney

Cost of Living

Joe Mantello

Three Tall Women

Patrick Marber

Travesties

2019

Sam Mendes

The Ferryman

Jack O'Brien

All My Sons

Rupert Goold

Ink

Logan Vaughn

The Light

Bartlett Sher

To Kill a Mockingbird

2020s

Year

Director

Production

Ref.

2020 (Hon.)

Kenny Leon

A Soldier's Play

Jamie Lloyd

Betrayal

John Ortiz

Halfway Bitches Go Straight to Heaven

Stephen Daldry

The Inheritance

David Cromer

The Sound Inside

2021

No award given due to COVID-19 pandemic.

2022

Sam Mendes

The Lehman Trilogy

Camille A. Brown

for colored girls who have considered suicide / when the rainbow is enuf

Ruben Santiago-Hudson

Skeleton Crew

Scott Ellis

Take Me Out

Anna D. Shapiro

The Minutes

2023

Patrick Marber

Leopoldstadt

Max Webster

Life of Pi

Pam MacKinnon

Downstate

Kenny Leon

Topdog/Underdog

Adam Meggido

Peter Pan Goes Wrong

2024

Daniel Aukin

Stereophonic

Knud Adams

Primary Trust

Kenny Leon

Purlie Victorious: A Non-Confederate Romp Through the Cotton Patch

Robert Falls

Swing State

Lila Neugebauer

Appropriate

2025

Danya Taymor

John Proctor is the Villain

Stephen Daldry and Justin Martin

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Phylicia Rashad

Purpose

Sam Mendes

The Hills of California

Trip Cullman

Cult of Love

2026

Joe Mantello

Death of a Salesman

Ngozi Anyanwu

The Monsters

Trip Cullman

Becky Shaw

Robert Icke

Oedipus

Debbie Allen

Joe Turner's Come and Gone

Tarell Alvin McCraney and Bijan Shibani

The Brothers Size

Multiple wins

4 wins
  • Jack O'Brien
3 wins
  • Joe Mantello
2 wins
  • Daniel J. Sullivan
  • Nicholas Hytner
  • Marianne Elliott
  • Sam Mendes

Multiple nominations

8 nominations
  • Daniel J. Sullivan
7 nominations
  • Joe Mantello
6 nominations
  • Jack O'Brien
4 nominations
  • Bartlett Sher
  • Kenny Leon
3 nominations
  • Anthony Page
  • Patrick Marber
  • Doug Hughes
  • Anna D. Shapiro
  • Rupert Goold
  • Michael Wilson
  • Marianne Elliott
  • Scott Ellis
  • Sam Mendes
  • Stephen Daldry
2 nominations
  • George C. Wolfe
  • Matthew Warchus
  • Garry Hynes
  • Robert Falls
  • Moisés Kaufman
  • Nicholas Hytner
  • Michael Grandage
  • Pam MacKinnon
  • Lila Neugebauer
  • Trip Cullman

See also

  • Tony Award for Best Direction of a Play
  • Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Director of a Play
  • Lucille Lortel Award for Outstanding Director

References

Outstanding Director of a Play