David Hays (merchant)

David Hays (died 1814) was a Jewish merchant and farmer in Bedford, New York, during the American Revolution. With his brother Benjamin he was among the earliest Jewish settlers of northern Westchester County. His house was burned by British forces in 1779, and his son Jacob Hays became New York City's long-serving high constable.

Family and early life

Hays belonged to a Jewish family that came to New York from Holland in the early 18th century. His father, Jacob Hays, was among those who erected the first building of Congregation Shearith Israel in 1730. David and his brother Benjamin moved to Bedford in 1762, where Benjamin kept a tavern and David a general store on the opposite side of the village common. He married Esther Etting.

American Revolution

Bedford lay in the "Neutral Ground" between the British and American lines, where families were often divided in their loyalties. According to the town's history, both David and Benjamin Hays served in the Westchester militia. In July 1779, during the British raid on Bedford led by Banastre Tarleton, David's house and Benjamin's tavern were among the buildings burned.

Family tradition, recorded by Solomon Solis-Cohen in 1894, holds that David was away supplying cattle to the American army at the time, and that his wife, bedridden with a newborn son, refused to tell the raiders where a party of Patriots driving cattle through the British lines could be found; their seven-year-old son Jacob was said to have been among the boys herding the animals. A 1951 account added that Hays had fought under Edward Braddock in the French and Indian War and declined pay for his Revolutionary service.

Later research has cast doubt on parts of this account. Investigating the family for a book on Jacob Hays, the writer Arthur Bringley found no record of David Hays among Braddock's soldiers and concluded that he may have sided with the Loyalists for much of the war before switching allegiance once an American victory seemed likely.

Later life

After the war Hays lived on a farm of about 170 acres near present-day Pleasantville, bought in 1785 from the state's Commissioners of Forfeiture, which sold land confiscated from Loyalists. He died there in 1814.